Skip to content
PT SCBI

Guide · Quality

Why Shisha Charcoal Batches Vary: Four Sources in Our Process and the Checks That Catch Drift

This guide belongs to the quality section and explains why batches of shisha charcoal, the hookah charcoal or hookah coals of US and Canadian buyers, differ from one another at this factory. It is written for the repeat buyer who compares one container with the last. It names the four stations where variation enters and the checks that catch it.

Written by
Henry Sinaga
Reviewed by
Dimas Setyawan,
Updated
Reading time
5 min read
Coconut shell charcoal is the carbonized shell of the coconut, a by-product of the copra and desiccated-coconut industries.

Quick answer

Why do batches of shisha charcoal vary, and how does this factory catch drift?

Batches vary with the shell charcoal bought, the mix, pressing and drying; the factory fails a batch on smell, high ash, cracks or uneven size. Each batch of coconut shell charcoal briquettes is checked per oven load, per day and per order, and a sample of every batch is retained. As of November 2026, one laboratory report is on file, so variation between shipments is not yet shown in figures.

1. What batch variation is

Batch variation is the difference between two batches made to the same specification.

Definition

batch variation

Batch variation is the difference in measured properties between production batches of one product made to one specification, arising from the raw material and from each production step.

At this factory a batch is identified by its production date: the batch number is the production date. Every batch is checked against the same limits, and a sample of each is retained, so a difference between two batches can be measured rather than argued.

How facts on this page are confirmed is set out in the editorial and review policy.

2. Four sources of variation

Variation can enter at four stations, and each one has its own control.

Where batch-to-batch variation can enter this factory's production of coconut shell charcoal briquettes, and the control at each station; process facts confirmed by the owner in November 2026, causes cited to FAO and a 2025 peer-reviewed study.
StationWhat can varyThe factory's control
Shell charcoal Carbonization differs between carbonizers; a low temperature and a short time raise volatile matter (FAO)Bought as carbonized shell charcoal from carbonizers in Sulawesi, East Nusa Tenggara (NTT) and Sumatra; intake checks: moisture below 12%, fixed carbon 82% or more, volatile matter 14% or less, ash content and ash color
The mix Particle size and the share of binder; the binder ratio is the main factor in briquette quality (2025 study)4 hammer mills, then a 10 m rotary sieve in 5 cleaning passes; binder: tapioca starch, typically 1.5–3% of the mix
Pressing The size and density of the piecesExtrusion only, with single laser-cut molds; size measured with a digital caliper on 20 pieces, 4 times a day
Drying The moisture left in the piecesElectric ovens, a slow cycle of 48 hours or more, to moisture of 2% at most; measured with a moisture meter on every oven load; 14 days of weathering
The mix is one of four stations where one batch can differ from the next.

Each station has its own page in the production process, where each cause sits, from intake to drying.

3. How drift is caught

Drift is caught by checks that run per oven load, per day and per order.

The checks that catch drift between batches of this factory's coconut shell charcoal briquettes, how often each runs and where its results go; as confirmed by the owner in November 2026.
CheckHow oftenWhere the result goes
Moisture at the oven Every oven loadOven readings, not published
Size 4 times a day, 20 pieces, written downThe size-deviation log
Drop test on lit pieces 350 per oven loadThe drop-strength log
Every piece by hand At packingNot published
Laboratory report A COA from the laboratory for each orderThe batch COA register

Caution

A batch fails on

  • Smell or smoke on warming up.
  • High ash.
  • Cracks or breakage.
  • Inconsistent size or density.
Size is measured with a digital caliper several times a day, and each check is written down.

Size results go to the size-deviation log, where drift shows row by row, and strength results to the drop-strength log; both gain rows once the factory's written records are confirmed.

4. What the records show today

As of November 2026, the batch COA register holds one confirmed report, and the size and drop logs hold no confirmed rows yet.

  • The batch COA register: one confirmed report; see the register.
  • The size-deviation log: no confirmed rows yet.
  • The drop-strength log: no confirmed rows yet.

One report cannot show variation between batches: the first difference shows only with a second shipment's report. Results from further shipments are added as they are tested.

5. Holding your specification across batches

Your specification is held across batches by a reference sample, a report for each order and a retained sample of every batch.

  1. Step 1

    The approved sample

    The reference. Split in two, one part to the buyer and one kept by the factory; sealed, signed by the factory and photographed.

    From sample to container

  2. Step 2

    A laboratory report for each order

    Each shipment. A COA from the laboratory for each order, so each shipment can be read against the last.

    The batch COA register

  3. Step 3

    A retained sample of every batch

    Kept after shipment. A sample of every batch, about 25 kg of each batch, kept for 5 years.

    Retained samples

The golden sample and the retained sample are what a later shipment is compared with, and every batch leaves the oven at moisture of 2% at most.

Questions buyers ask

Will my second container match my first?
Not exactly, because no two batches are identical. Each batch is held to the same limits and checks, the shipment of each order gets its own laboratory report, and a sample of every batch is kept for 5 years, so a difference can be measured and traced.
What is a batch at this factory?
A batch is identified by its production date: the batch number is the production date. The retained sample of each batch is kept in a sealed bag labeled with that batch number and date.

Sources

  1. Simple technologies for charcoal making (FAO Forestry Paper 41), chapter 10: Using charcoal efficiently (opens in new tab), Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations — accessed
  2. Madhusanka et al. (2025), Evaluating Non-Edible Binders in Coconut Shell Biochar and Cinnamon Sawdust Briquettes, AgriEngineering 7(5), 132 (opens in new tab), MDPI — accessed

Test before you commit a container

Samples ship with the batch COA; third-party inspection on request.