Skip to content
PT SCBI

Policy · Quality

Claims and Remedies: Reporting a Shortage or a Quality Problem After a Container Arrives

This page belongs to the quality section and states the factory's rule for a problem found after a container order of shisha charcoal, the hookah charcoal or hookah coals of US and Canadian buyers, has arrived. It is written for the buyer who signs for the container. There are two windows: 7 days for a shortage and 14 days for a quality problem.

Written by
Henry Sinaga
Reviewed by
Dimas Setyawan,
Updated
Reading time
4 min read

Quick answer

What do I do if a container arrives short or below specification, and what does the factory do about it?

A shortage is reported within 7 days and a quality problem within 14 days of arrival at your warehouse; the remedy is credit or discount. The remedy applies to the next order. A claim on a container of shisha charcoal is checked against the specification on the proforma invoice, the approved sample and the retained sample of the batch. The evidence the factory asks for is not on file yet.

1. What this policy covers

The policy covers two kinds of problem found after arrival: a shortage and a quality problem.

Definition

claims process

A claims process is a seller's written procedure for a buyer's complaint after delivery: the time limit for reporting it, what the complaint is checked against, and the remedy offered.

Two things are outside it. Damage in transit follows the term of sale, which decides who arranged the insurance: see the incoterms page, under Incoterms. A change asked for before shipment follows the order change policy on the changes and cancellations page.

How facts on this page are confirmed is set out in the editorial and review policy.

2. The claim windows

Each kind of claim has its own window, and both are counted from the same day.

Time limits for reporting a claim on a container of coconut shell charcoal briquettes from this factory, in days, as stated by the owner in November 2026.
Kind of claimReport withinCounted from
A shortage (quantity) 7 daysArrival of the container at the buyer's warehouse
A quality problem 14 daysArrival of the container at the buyer's warehouse

Check the seal number against the bill of lading before the doors are opened, and count the cartons as they come out. A shortage found during unloading is inside its window.

3. What to send with a claim

A claim can be checked only if it names the container and shows what was found.

  • The container and seal numbers, as they appear on the bill of lading.
  • Photographs of the seal before it is cut, of the cartons as they stand in the container, and of the carton marks.
  • The count against the packing list, carton by carton, for a shortage.
  • The measurement, for a quality problem: what was measured, how, and on how many pieces, set against the specification on the proforma invoice.

Note

Guidance, not the factory's list

The factory's own list of required evidence is not on file yet. The four items above are what makes a claim checkable, and they are offered as guidance.

The contact page is where to send the claim. It is answered by the Export Sales Manager, Irfan Maulana, within 15 minutes during working hours (WIB), or the next working day outside them.

4. What a claim is checked against

A claim is compared with what was agreed and with what was kept.

  • The specification. The proforma invoice states the full specification, the packaging and the volume. The grade on it is an ash range, and the stated size tolerance is ±0.3 mm per side.
  • The approved sample. It is kept so reorders can be matched to the previous order, and it is packed and labeled with the order it belongs to.
  • The retained sample. On file: a sample of every batch, about 25 kg of each batch, kept for 5 years. When a claim is raised, the retained sample of the batch is compared with what the buyer reports; part of it can be sent to a laboratory, though not to the buyer.
  • The record of the container. Written down for each container: date of production, date of packing and temperature on the day of packing.

The log of those samples will be published on the page for the retained sample a claim is checked against.

When the two sides disagree, a laboratory or a surveyor can be asked to decide, with the cost shared. Who makes the comparison, and how long it takes, are not on file, so this page does not state them.

5. The remedy

One remedy is on file, and it is applied to the next order.

For a claim that is accepted, the remedy is credit or discount on the next order.

Note

Not on file

  • A replacement shipment.
  • A refund.
  • The return of goods.
  • A remedy for a buyer who places no further order.

If your purchase needs one of these, agree it in writing with the export desk before the deposit is paid.

6. Before it comes to a claim

Three checks come before a claim, and each can catch a problem while the goods are still at the factory.

  • Approve a sample. The order is then made to match it: see the sample-to-container page, under golden sample.
  • Send your inspector. Buyers' third-party inspectors are welcome before shipment; the factory pays for the pre-shipment inspection. The steps are on the pre-shipment inspection page.
  • The independent surveyor. An independent surveyor inspects the load before shipment; the factory pays, inside the FOB price. Whether the buyer receives the surveyor's report is not on file, so ask for it.

Measured values for a batch belong in the batch COA register, which shows rows once the first are confirmed.

Questions buyers ask

How long do I have to report a problem?
7 days for a shortage and 14 days for a quality problem. Both are counted from the arrival of the container at the buyer's warehouse, not from the date the vessel docks. Check the seal and count the cartons as you unload, so a shortage is found inside its window.
Is the remedy a refund?
The remedy on file is credit or discount on the next order. A replacement shipment, a refund or the return of goods is not on file, so this page does not offer one. If your purchase needs a different remedy, agree it in writing with the export desk before you pay the deposit.
What will my claim be compared with?
With what was agreed and what was kept: the specification on your proforma invoice, the approved sample the factory keeps, and the retained sample of your batch, which is kept for 5 years. When a claim is raised, the retained sample of the batch is compared with what the buyer reports; part of it can be sent to a laboratory, though not to the buyer. Who decides, and how fast, is not on file yet.

Spotted an error?

Report it — corrections are dated on this page.