Skip to content
PT SCBI

Guide · Quality

Sample Test Protocol for Shisha Charcoal: One Setup, One Record Sheet, Compared With the Batch COA

This protocol belongs to the quality and consistency section and is written for a QC or purchasing team with a parcel of shisha charcoal on the bench, often beside a second supplier's. Lounge buyers in the US and Canada know the same product as hookah charcoal or hookah coals. The rule is one setup for every candidate and one sheet, read beside the batch COA.

Written by
Henry Sinaga
Updated
Reading time
7 min read
A burn test records ignition time, heat stability and the ash left after a full burn under one fixed bowl-and-airflow setup.

Quick answer

How do I test a shisha charcoal sample so the result is comparable and useful?

A sample test is useful only when every candidate runs through one fixed setup and results sit on one record sheet beside the batch COA. This protocol runs seven steps on a 1 kg sample of coconut shell charcoal briquettes and records each field against the COA field or spec sheet line it is compared with. The approved sheet becomes the baseline for your first container.

1. What this protocol is for

A sample test is worth running only when its numbers can be compared — with another candidate, or with the documents the sample came with.

Definition

sample test

A sample test is a buyer-side evaluation of a charcoal sample that records lighting time, burn behavior, ash, smell, dimensions and breakage under one fixed setup so that candidates can be compared and the approved sample fixed.

The results have two uses. The first is choosing between candidates: samples from two or three suppliers, or two grades from one supplier, run through the same setup on the same day. The second is fixing the approved sample: the sheet you fill for the sample you approve records what the first container has to match. Both uses depend on one rule — every candidate goes through the same heat source, bowl, airflow and steps, written down before the first piece is lit.

Note

A bench test cannot measure laboratory values: moisture, ash, volatile matter and fixed carbon come from the batch COA, and calorific value needs a laboratory report that states it. One parcel also cannot show whether later batches will match it; that is the subject of the sample-to-bulk consistency page and the batch COA register.

2. Before you start: the parcel, the room, the equipment

Before the first bag is opened, copy four things from the parcel onto the sheet: the batch number on the bag label, the production date, the shape and size, and the grade.

The batch number is the key to the whole test: it ties every measurement on the sheet to one batch COA. What a shisha charcoal sample contains and which documents travel with it are set out on the samples page; if a document is missing, ask for it before testing rather than after.

The batch number on a sample bag's label is what links each record-sheet measurement to the batch COA of the same production batch.

Keep the bags sealed, dry and at room temperature until test day, and open each bag on the day it is tested: pieces take up moisture from humid air, and a bag opened a week early is no longer the sample that was sent. The equipment fits on one bench:

  • a scale reading to 0.1 g;
  • a caliper reading to 0.1 mm, or a steel rule for a rougher check;
  • a stopwatch;
  • an electric coil, or the gas burner your lounges use;
  • one bowl and one heat-management device, the same for every candidate;
  • tongs and a metal tray for the ash;
  • a marked height of 1 m above a concrete floor for the drop check;
  • the record sheet in section 5, one copy per candidate.

Caution

Burning charcoal releases carbon monoxide, a gas with no color and no smell. Run every test in a ventilated room or under extraction, never in a closed room, and keep the coil and the hot ash away from anything that can catch fire.

3. The fixed setup

Choose the heat source, the bowl and device, the airflow and the room once, write them in the setup block at the top of the sheet, and change nothing until the last candidate is finished.

Setup block of the record sheet: the four settings written once per session and kept unchanged for every candidate tested in it.
SettingWhat to write downWhy it stays fixed
Heat source Coil model and setting, or burner and flame settingIgnition time depends on how much heat reaches the contact face
Bowl and heat-management device Bowl type and device modelBurn duration and heat stability depend on how the device holds and vents heat
Airflow Fan on or off, window open or closed, extraction on or offMoving air speeds combustion and carries ash off the tray
Room Temperature, and the day each bag was openedPieces take up moisture from humid air, which slows ignition

Two settings in particular make results incomparable when they vary: flame contact and airflow. A gas flame heats a piece unevenly depending on the burner and the distance, and a fan or an open window speeds combustion and carries ash away, so the same charcoal can light faster and seem to leave less ash on one day than on the next. Start every candidate from a cold coil, let the same person run the steps, and test all candidates on the same day where you can.

4. The test, step by step

Run the seven steps in order on one candidate, write each result down as you go, and finish the sheet before the next bag is opened.

  1. Step 1

    Count and weigh the bag

    Pieces per kilogram. Weigh the opened bag and count every piece in it. Divide the count by the mass in kilograms and write the result as pieces per kg; it is compared with the spec sheet line for your shape and size.

  2. Step 2

    Measure ten pieces

    Three dimensions, one mass. Take ten pieces at random, not the ten that look best. Measure length, width and height of each with the caliper, weigh each piece, and mark every piece that falls outside the dimension band on the spec sheet.

  3. Step 3

    Drop the same ten pieces

    One meter, onto concrete. Drop each measured piece once from 1 m onto a concrete floor. Count a piece as broken when it splits into two or more parts, and note chipped edges separately.

  4. Step 4

    Ignite three new pieces

    Time to full glow. Weigh three unused pieces together and place them on the heat source at the setting in the setup block. Start the stopwatch when they touch the heat and stop it when every face is covered in grey ash and glowing. Note any smell or smoke while they light.

  5. Step 5

    Burn one bowl

    To the end of useful heat. Move the three lit pieces to the bowl and the heat-management device and run them as your lounges would, until the heat is no longer useful. Record the duration in minutes, how many times the pieces had to be repositioned, and whether a piece was added.

  6. Step 6

    Collect and weigh the ash

    A bench figure, not COA. Let the ash cool on the metal tray, weigh it, and divide by the starting mass of the three pieces to get ash as a percentage of burned mass. Note its color and whether the pieces kept their shape as ash.

  7. Step 7

    Complete the sheet

    Before the next candidate. Fill every field before the next bag is opened. Let the coil cool to room temperature so the next candidate starts from the same cold setup.

Steps 1 to 3 check the pieces against the spec sheet, steps 4 to 6 record how the batch behaves in your setup, and step 7 keeps the candidates apart.

Samples from two suppliers are comparable on a bench only when both run through the same heat source, bowl, device and airflow in one session.

5. The record sheet

The record sheet has one row per measurement and one column that matters more than the others: what each figure is compared with.

Record sheet for the buyer-side sample test; the compared-with column names the batch COA field or spec sheet line each measurement is checked against, or marks it as comparable between candidates only.
FieldHow measuredUnitCompared with
Batch number Copied from the bag labeltextCOA header
Pieces per kg Piece count divided by bag masspieces/kgSpec sheet line for the shape and size
Dimensions Caliper, ten pieces, three dimensions eachmmSpec sheet dimension band
Piece mass Scale, the same ten piecesgSpec sheet line, where stated
Drop breakage The same ten pieces, 1 m onto concretepieces broken of 10Spec sheet line, where stated; otherwise candidate to candidate
Ignition time Three pieces on the heat sourceminutesCandidate to candidate only
Burn duration One bowlminutesCandidate to candidate only
Heat stability Repositionings during the bowlcountCandidate to candidate only
Ash mass Tray and scale% of burned mass (bench)Candidate to candidate only; not the COA ash field
Ash color and shape ObservationnoteCandidate to candidate only
Smell and smoke at ignition ObservationnoteCandidate to candidate only

Every field points either to a document, the COA header or a spec sheet line, or to the other candidates. The table prints on one page: fill one copy per candidate with the setup block at the top, and keep the approved copy for the arrival check on your first container, where the dimension, mass and breakage rows are measured again on pieces taken from the cartons.

6. Reading your results against the COA

Read the sheet in two halves: the fields that can be checked against the documents, and the fields that only rank candidates.

Batch number, pieces per kg, dimensions, piece mass and, where the spec sheet states a line, drop breakage are compared with the spec sheet and the COA header. The COA fields your results are compared with are explained one by one, with the method each is measured by.

Ignition time, burn duration, heat stability, bench ash and smell are bench-only. They depend on your coil, bowl, device and room, so they rank candidates against each other and against what your lounges expect; they are never compared with a factory figure. A bench ash weight is not the COA ash percentage either: the laboratory heats a portion in a furnace by a stated method, while a bowl burn stops when the heat fades and loses ash to airflow.

Laboratory COA and bench test compared by method, sample, moisture basis, level and use; the two answer different questions and are read side by side.
AspectLaboratory COABench test
Method A named test method, stated on the reportThis protocol, in your setup
Sample A prepared portion of the batchPieces as received in the parcel
Moisture basis Stated on the report, for example dry or air-driedAs received, at room conditions
Level One production batchIndividual pieces
Use Compare with the spec sheetCompare candidates

Important

A result outside a spec sheet band is a disqualifier: the sample does not match its own documents, and it should not be approved until the difference is explained. A result that depends on your device, such as a longer ignition, a shorter bowl or a smell you dislike, is a note: it may rule a candidate out for your lounges, but it says nothing about whether the batch meets its specification.

7. After the test

Every test ends in one of three branches, and each one ends with the sheet in a file.

The sample you approve becomes the golden sample, so the sheet you filled for it is the written half of that reference. A sample you set aside is still useful: the field that failed tells the export desk which shisha charcoal grade, shape or size to send next.

  1. Report the approved sample

    Approved. Tell the export desk which bag you approved and send the completed sheet with its batch number, so your first order names the sample it has to match.

    How the approved sample is split and sealed

  2. Name the field that failed

    Not approved. Tell the export desk which field failed and by how much, so the next sample is a different shape, size or grade rather than the same one again.

    What changes from one grade to the next

  3. Keep one sheet per candidate

    Approved or not. File every sheet with its setup block. The approved sheet is the baseline for the arrival check on your first container; the others show why a candidate was set aside.

    The arrival check on your first container

If no parcel has arrived yet, request the sample this protocol is written for and print the sheet before it lands.

Questions buyers ask

Can I test your sample and another supplier's sample side by side?
Yes, and that is what the protocol is built for. Run both through the same setup on the same day, one after the other, with the heat source cooled between them, and fill one record sheet per candidate. Fields marked candidate to candidate on the sheet, such as ignition time, burn duration and smell, only mean something in that comparison.
Why is the ash I weigh after a burn different from the ash figure on the COA?
They measure different things. The laboratory heats a portion in a furnace until only ash remains, by the method named on the COA, and reports a percentage on a stated basis. A bowl burn stops when the heat fades and loses ash to airflow and handling. Compare bench figures between candidates, and the COA figure with the spec sheet.
How many pieces do I need to test?
This protocol uses ten pieces for the size, mass and drop checks and three more for ignition and the bowl burn, which leaves most of the parcel for a repeat run. The counts are the protocol's choice for repeatability, not a standard; use more if your decision rests on one field, and keep the counts equal across candidates.
Electric coil or gas flame for ignition?
Either, as long as every candidate uses the same one. The protocol describes an electric coil because flame contact varies with the burner and the distance, which makes ignition times incomparable between sessions. If your lounges light on gas, test on gas and write the burner and setting on the sheet.
Does the sample test replace the laboratory COA?
No. The COA states the batch's ash, moisture, volatile matter and fixed carbon under stated methods; the sample test tells you how that batch behaves in your device and whether its pieces match the spec sheet. Read the two side by side: the COA for laboratory values, your sheet for behavior.

Test before you commit a container

Samples ship with the batch COA; third-party inspection on request.