Quick answer
What causes sparking, smell or breakage in a delivery, and how do I claim?
Three symptoms are covered here (sparking, smell at ignition and breakage), each traced to its likely cause, the record to check and the claim route. For each symptom in coconut shell charcoal briquettes, test the pieces beside your half of the approved sample, then report a quality problem within 14 days of the container's arrival at your warehouse.
1. What counts as a defect
A defect is judged against what was agreed, not against a preference.
Definition
charcoal defect
A charcoal defect, for coconut shell charcoal briquettes, is a property of delivered pieces, such as sparking, an off smell at ignition or breakage, that departs from the agreed specification or the approved sample.
The references are the proforma invoice, which is the specification at this factory, and the approved sample. That sample is split in two, one part to the buyer and one kept by the factory; sealed, signed by the factory and photographed. A symptom is compared with your half of the approved sample, burned the same way, before it is raised.
How facts on this page are confirmed is set out in the editorial and review policy.
2. Symptom, likely cause and the record to check
Each symptom has likely causes, a check at the factory and a record to ask for.
| Symptom | Likely causes | What the factory checks | Record to ask for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sparking | Foreign matter such as earth or sand; moisture held in the piece (FAO) | Intake checks; a rotary sieve; moisture on every oven load | The shipment's laboratory report; the retained sample of the batch |
| Smell at ignition | The binder; volatile matter; moisture taken up in storage (FAO; 2025 study) | Volatile matter at intake; a batch that smells or smokes on warming up fails | The shipment's laboratory report; the retained sample of the batch |
| Breakage and dust | Pressing, drying, handling and the carton (2025 study; FAO) | A drop test on lit pieces; every piece checked by hand at packing | The drop-strength log; the photographs of the load sent at loading |
Each symptom has its own page: why shisha charcoal sparks, smell at ignition and breakage and dust. What each laboratory figure measures is explained in the parameters behind each symptom.
3. Before you claim: test it the same way
Before a claim, test the problem pieces the way the approved sample was tested.
-
Step 1
Keep the cartons and note the dates
Before you open more. Set the affected cartons aside with their contents, and write down the carton marks and the date the container arrived.
-
Step 2
Photograph what you see
With a scale. Photograph the pieces, the ash or the breaks beside a ruler, and the outer cartons they came from.
-
Step 3
Repeat the test on the same setup
Like with like. Light the pieces on the device, bowl and airflow you used for your sample test, as the sample test protocol sets out.
-
Step 4
Burn the approved sample beside them
The reference. Run your half of the approved sample in the same session, so the comparison is fair.
The bench method is set out in the sample test protocol, and the reference is your half of the golden sample.
4. The claim route
A quality problem is reported within 14 days and a shortage within 7 days of the arrival of the container at the buyer's warehouse.
| Step | On file |
|---|---|
| Reporting a quality problem | Within 14 days of the arrival of the container at the buyer's warehouse |
| Reporting a shortage | Within 7 days of the arrival of the container at the buyer's warehouse |
| What your report is compared with | When a claim is raised, the retained sample of the batch is compared with what the buyer reports; part of it can be sent to a laboratory, though not to the buyer |
| A disputed claim | A laboratory or a surveyor can be asked to decide, with the cost shared |
| Remedy | Credit or discount on the next order |
The full claims process, with what is not on file yet, is on the page about turning a confirmed defect into a claim. The retained sample it relies on is described on the retained samples page.
Questions buyers ask
Can a third party settle a disputed claim?
Which symptoms are not covered here?
Sources
- Simple technologies for charcoal making (FAO Forestry Paper 41), chapter 10: Using charcoal efficiently (opens in new tab), Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations — accessed
- Simple technologies for charcoal making (FAO Forestry Paper 41), chapter 9: Transport, storage and distribution of charcoal (opens in new tab), Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations — accessed
- Mencarelli, Greco and Grigolato (2025), Grilling and air pollution: how charcoal quality affects emissions, Air Quality, Atmosphere & Health 18, 1757–1770 (opens in new tab), Springer Nature — accessed
- Madhusanka et al. (2025), Evaluating Non-Edible Binders in Coconut Shell Biochar and Cinnamon Sawdust Briquettes, AgriEngineering 7(5), 132 (opens in new tab), MDPI — accessed