Skip to content
PT SCBI

Guide · Troubleshooting

Breakage and Dust in Shisha Charcoal: Pressing, Drying, Handling or the Carton

This page belongs to the troubleshooting guide and covers broken pieces and dust in shisha charcoal, the hookah charcoal or hookah coals of US and Canadian buyers. It is written for the importer who opens cartons with broken pieces. It names four causes, the factory's drop test and what to record on arrival.

Written by
Henry Sinaga
Reviewed by
Dimas Setyawan,
Updated
Reading time
4 min read
Lit pieces are dropped onto a hard tiled floor from a set height and checked for breaks.

Quick answer

Why does shisha charcoal break or arrive with dust, and what is checked?

Breakage comes from pressing, drying, handling or the carton; this factory drop-tests lit pieces from 350 per oven load and fails a batch with cracks. For coconut shell charcoal briquettes that arrive broken, photograph the cartons before unloading and report a shortage within 7 days or a quality problem within 14 days of arrival.

1. What breakage is

Breakage can happen in production, in the carton or in use, and each points to a different cause.

Definition

breakage

Breakage, for coconut shell charcoal briquettes, is the cracking or splitting of pieces, and the fragments and dust it leaves, whether it happens in production, in the carton or in use.

Some fines come from every movement of charcoal: FAO's handbook on charcoal making notes that most are produced in loading and unloading, and that each movement produces some. What matters is breakage beyond what your sample showed.

How facts on this page are confirmed is set out in the editorial and review policy.

2. Four causes

Four causes are checked: two in production and two after it.

Four causes of breakage and dust in coconut shell charcoal briquettes and this factory's control for each; controls as confirmed by the owner in November 2026.
CauseWhat can happenThe factory's control
Pressing Pieces with too little binder, or pressed too loosely, hold together less wellExtrusion only, with single laser-cut molds; binder: tapioca starch, typically 1.5–3% of the mix
Drying A badly dried piece can crackElectric ovens, a slow cycle of 48 hours or more, to moisture of 2% at most
Handling Every movement of charcoal makes some finesPacked by the in-house team, who check every piece by hand
The carton A damaged carton gives the pieces less protectionMaster cartons: kraft K150/M125K150, single-wall B-flute, up to 3 colors; inner boxes: duplex 250 gsm over E-flute, CMYK offset print, varnish finish

A 2025 peer-reviewed study of coconut shell biochar briquettes found the binder ratio to be the main factor in briquette quality, with binder content raising mechanical strength and durability, and treats drying as the step that hardens a briquette and limits the risk of cracking. Each master carton is specified on the master cartons page, with the board on file.

Master cartons carry the inner boxes through every move from the packing line to the buyer's warehouse.

3. The drop test

The factory drop-tests lit pieces, 350 per oven load, and a batch with cracks fails.

The drop test this factory runs on its coconut shell charcoal briquettes, as confirmed by the owner in November 2026.
ItemOn file
Pieces tested 350 per oven load
Drop height Cube: 100 cm; Hexagonal, dome and finger: 30 cm
Surface A hard tiled floor
State of the pieces Lit pieces, after 10 minutes of heating and 5 minutes on a shisha bowl
Pass A piece passes if it does not break in at least 3 drops

Results go to the drop-strength log, which has no confirmed rows yet. Cracks or breakage is one of four reasons a batch fails.

4. What to check when cartons arrive with broken pieces

When cartons arrive with broken pieces, record the state of the load before anything is moved.

  1. Step 1

    Photograph before unloading

    As the doors open. Photograph the load as the container is opened, then any crushed, torn or wet cartons.

  2. Step 2

    Separate carton damage from piece damage

    Outside and inside. Note whether broken pieces sit in cartons damaged on the outside, or in cartons that arrived intact.

  3. Step 3

    Compare with the load photographs

    From loading. Photographs of the load are taken and sent to the buyer; set them beside your own.

  4. Step 4

    Report within the window

    Quantity and quality. A shortage is reported within 7 days and a quality problem within 14 days of the arrival of the container at the buyer's warehouse.

Photograph opened cartons and their contents before the pieces are moved.

Carton damage in transit and breakage from production point to different causes, so say which you see when you report it. The route is on the claims and remedies page; the other symptoms, sparking and smell at ignition, are traced on the troubleshooting page.

Questions buyers ask

Is some dust in the carton to be expected?
Some fines come from every movement of charcoal: FAO's charcoal handbook notes that most are produced in loading and unloading. Every piece is checked by hand at packing, so report a carton with more broken pieces or dust than your sample showed.
Why does the factory drop lit pieces rather than cold ones?
The test is run on pieces in the state they are handled in use: lit, after 10 minutes of heating and 5 minutes on a shisha bowl. A piece passes if it does not break in at least 3 drops.

Sources

  1. Madhusanka et al. (2025), Evaluating Non-Edible Binders in Coconut Shell Biochar and Cinnamon Sawdust Briquettes, AgriEngineering 7(5), 132 (opens in new tab), MDPI — accessed
  2. Simple technologies for charcoal making (FAO Forestry Paper 41), chapter 9: Transport, storage and distribution of charcoal (opens in new tab), Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations — accessed

Test before you commit a container

Samples ship with the batch COA; third-party inspection on request.