Quick answer
Why does shisha charcoal spark, and what does this factory do about it?
Sparking can point to foreign matter or trapped moisture in a piece; the factory fails a batch that smokes or smells on warming up. The laboratory report does not measure sparking in coconut shell charcoal briquettes, so test a carton kept dry beside the one that sparked, and look for grit in the ash, before raising it within 14 days of arrival.
1. What sparking is
Sparking is seen, not measured: no result on the laboratory report records it.
Definition
sparking
Sparking, for coconut shell charcoal briquettes, is the throwing of glowing particles from a lit piece while it heats, an observation made by eye rather than a laboratory result.
The report on file states moisture, ash, volatile matter and fixed carbon, and none of them measures sparks. Sparking is judged by eye, in use or in a sample test, so its cause in a given piece is something to test, not to read off a report.
How facts on this page are confirmed is set out in the editorial and review policy.
2. Two likely causes
Two causes are checked first: foreign matter in the piece, and moisture held inside it.
| Likely cause | What the source says | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Foreign matter | FAO's handbook names earth and sand contamination among the causes of high ash in charcoal, and notes that charcoal fines can carry mineral sand and clay picked up from the ground. | Grit or hard specks in the ash of the pieces that sparked |
| Moisture held in the piece | FAO notes that charcoal takes up moisture from humid air quickly, and that the water must be evaporated on burning. | Pieces from a damp or opened carton sparking more than pieces from a carton kept dry |
A spark alone proves neither cause, and the device and the way a piece is lit can play a part. The checks in section 4 separate the two.
3. What the factory does against it
The factory works against both causes at intake, at the sieve, at the oven and at the batch check.
| Step | What is done | Against |
|---|---|---|
| Intake | Each delivery is checked: moisture below 12%, fixed carbon 82% or more, volatile matter 14% or less, ash content and ash color | Foreign matter and moisture |
| Milling | 4 hammer mills, then a 10 m rotary sieve in 5 cleaning passes | Foreign matter |
| Drying | Electric ovens, a slow cycle of 48 hours or more, to moisture of 2% at most; measured with a moisture meter on every oven load | Moisture |
| Weathering | 14 days, under cover in the open air, after production and before packing | Rain on finished pieces |
| Batch check | A batch fails on smell or smoke on warming up | Faults that show as a batch heats |
| Packing | Packed by the in-house team, who check every piece by hand | Visible defects |
The checks on each delivery of shell charcoal are set out in how incoming shell charcoal is checked, and drying on the drying page.
4. What to check when pieces spark
When pieces spark, four checks narrow the cause before a claim.
-
Step 1
Note the carton
Which pieces. Write down the carton marks, and whether the carton was opened, damp or kept in humid air.
-
Step 2
Test a dry carton beside it
Moisture first. Light pieces from a carton kept closed and dry beside pieces from the carton that sparked, on the same setup.
-
Step 3
Look at the ash
Grit or not. After the burn, look for grit or hard specks in the ash of the pieces that sparked.
-
Step 4
Read the shipment's report
Ash and moisture. Compare the ash and moisture on the shipment's laboratory report with the grade range and with earlier reports.
If the cause points to the charcoal, report it within 14 days of the arrival of the container at the buyer's warehouse. The route is on the troubleshooting page and the claims and remedies page, and the retained sample of the batch is what your report is compared with. Broken pieces and dust have a page of their own: breakage and dust.
Questions buyers ask
Does the laboratory report show whether a batch will spark?
Can sparking start after delivery?
Sources
- Simple technologies for charcoal making (FAO Forestry Paper 41), chapter 10: Using charcoal efficiently (opens in new tab), Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations — accessed
- Simple technologies for charcoal making (FAO Forestry Paper 41), chapter 9: Transport, storage and distribution of charcoal (opens in new tab), Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations — accessed