Skip to content
PT SCBI

Guide · Quality

From Sample to Container #5: How Your Approved Sample Is Held

This guide belongs to the quality section and is written for a buyer who has approved, or is about to approve, a sample of shisha charcoal, the hookah charcoal or hookah coals of US and Canadian buyers. It follows that sample to the container and to the reorder. Each step states what the factory has confirmed and what is not on file yet.

Written by
Henry Sinaga
Reviewed by
Dimas Setyawan,
Updated
Reading time
5 min read
An approved sample kept as a physical reference lets a later order be compared with what the buyer signed off.

Quick answer

How does this factory make sure the container matches the sample I approved — and the fifth container matches the first?

The approved sample is kept so reorders can be matched to it, and a sample of every batch is retained for 5 years. Every sample ships with its batch COA, and the specification of an order is stated on the proforma invoice. If a container of shisha charcoal still differs, a quality claim can be raised within 14 days of its arrival.

1. What a sample proves, and what it cannot

A shisha charcoal sample describes the batch it was drawn from, and the container is a later batch.

Definition

golden sample

A golden sample is the buyer-approved sample of a product, sealed and retained in two halves by buyer and factory, that serves as the physical reference against which the first container and later reorders are checked.

At this factory, every sample ships with its batch certificate of analysis (COA). That COA describes the sample's own batch. It shows what the factory can make; what your order must be is written in the specification.

The samples page covers what to test on your sample, and how to request it, and the test itself is on the sample test protocol. How facts on this page are confirmed is set out in the editorial and review policy.

2. The golden sample: the approved sample, kept

The sample you approve becomes the reference for later orders, and the factory keeps it.

The factory's rule, in its own words: the approved sample is kept so reorders can be matched to the previous order. For that purpose, the approved sample is packed and labeled with the order it belongs to.

How the approved sample is kept: it is split in two, one part to the buyer and one kept by the factory; sealed, signed by the factory and photographed.

Note

Not on file yet

  • Where the buyer's part is kept.

On your own side, keep part of the sample you approved in a sealed bag. Label it with the date, the shape, the grade and the batch reference on its COA, so both sides hold the same reference.

Setting a new delivery beside the approved sample is the simplest comparison a buyer can make on arrival.

3. The specification on the proforma invoice

The numeric reference is the specification on the proforma invoice.

The proforma invoice states the full specification, the packaging and the volume. Two limits on file go into that specification:

  • The grade. Each shisha charcoal grade is set by an ash range, from 1.6–1.9% for Platinum to 2.3–2.5% for Premium.
  • The size. The stated size tolerance is ±0.3 mm per side.

No moisture, fixed carbon or volatile matter limit is stated per grade. The ranges are on the grades and specifications page, and the proforma invoice on the payment terms page.

4. Before shipment: batch checks and your inspector

Before a container leaves, the batch has passed the factory's own checks, and you can send your own inspector.

  • What fails a batch: smell or smoke on warming up, high ash, cracks or breakage and inconsistent size or density.
  • Your inspector: Buyers' third-party inspectors are welcome before shipment; the factory pays for the pre-shipment inspection.
  • The surveyor: an independent surveyor inspects the load before shipment; the factory pays, inside the FOB price.

Whether a certificate of analysis is issued for every batch of an order is not confirmed yet, so this page does not promise one. The in-line checks are on the quality checkpoints page, and measured values belong in the batch COA register on the batch COA register page.

5. The retained sample and a claim

If a container still differs from what you approved, two things are on file: a retained sample and a claim window.

  • Retained: a sample of every batch, about 25 kg of each batch, kept for 5 years.
  • A shortage: reported within 7 days of the arrival of the container at the buyer's warehouse.
  • A quality problem: reported within 14 days; the remedy is credit or discount on the next order.
A retained sample is a labeled part of a production batch that stays at the factory after the container has shipped.

The retained-samples page will list the retained samples the comparison is made against, and the claims page sets out what to do if a container drifts from the sample. When a claim is raised, the retained sample of the batch is compared with what the buyer reports; part of it can be sent to a laboratory, though not to the buyer. Who makes the comparison, and how long it takes, is not on file yet.

6. Reorders: matched to the previous order

A reorder is matched to the order before it, and the kept sample is what it is matched to.

The factory sells order by order and a repeat program with reserved capacity. Either way, each order has its own proforma invoice, and its specification is the one the batch is held to.

A change to an order follows one rule: changes after the deposit are confirmed with the buyer before they take effect. Repeat orders are covered on the reorders page, and moving from another supplier on the switching and second source page.

Questions buyers ask

My last supplier's container did not match the sample. How is this different?
Four things are on file here. The approved sample is kept so reorders can be matched to the previous order. A sample of every batch is retained: a sample of every batch, about 25 kg of each batch, kept for 5 years. Your own inspector can check the goods before shipment, at the factory's cost. And a quality claim can be raised within 14 days of the container's arrival at your warehouse.
Will the container be identical to the sample?
No container is identical to a sample, because the container is a later batch. What is agreed is the specification on the proforma invoice: the grade, whose limit is an ash range, and the shape and size, with a stated tolerance of ±0.3 mm per side. The approved sample is the physical reference later orders are matched to.
How long do you keep the retained sample, and can I ask for it?
The rule on file is a sample of every batch, about 25 kg of each batch, kept for 5 years. When a claim is raised, the retained sample of the batch is compared with what the buyer reports; part of it can be sent to a laboratory, though not to the buyer.
What if I change the specification between orders?
A new order has its own proforma invoice, which states the specification, the packaging and the volume, so a change between orders is written there. After a deposit, a change takes effect only once the factory has confirmed it with you. Where a change affects how the charcoal looks or burns, ask for a new sample and approve it first.

Test before you commit a container

Samples ship with the batch COA; third-party inspection on request.