Skip to content
PT SCBI

Guide · Production process

Quality Checkpoints in Production: The In-Line Checks and What Fails a Batch

This guide is part of briquette production and is written for a buyer or QC lead asking what the factory checks itself while it makes shisha charcoal, the hookah charcoal or hookah coals of US and Canadian buyers. It covers the checks at several stations, in line order. Only confirmed checks are listed, each with its criterion and its record.

Written by
Henry Sinaga
Reviewed by
Dimas Setyawan,
Updated
Reading time
4 min read
A digital caliper reads to 0.01 mm; the size tolerance of a briquette is stated per side against its nominal dimension.

Quick answer

Which in-line checks does a batch pass, and what makes a batch fail?

A batch fails for smell or smoke on warming up, high ash, cracks or breakage, or inconsistent size or density. Before that, incoming shell charcoal is checked against intake limits and each batch of shisha charcoal must reach the oven moisture limit; at packing, the in-house team checks every piece by hand. Results go to the registers linked from the quality hub, which show rows once confirmed.

1. What a quality checkpoint is

A quality checkpoint is a check the factory runs itself, at a fixed point in the line.

Definition

quality checkpoint

A quality checkpoint is a fixed point in production where a batch is checked against a stated criterion and is released, held or rejected before it moves to the next station.

In-line checks are not laboratory results. A certificate of analysis reports laboratory values for a batch, and those belong to the batch COA register on the batch COA register page.

How facts on this page are confirmed is set out in the editorial and review policy.

2. The checkpoints, from intake to packing

Six checks are on file, from the delivery of shell charcoal to the packed carton.

In-line checks confirmed by the owner for this factory's production of coconut shell charcoal briquettes, with the criterion on file for each and the register its results go to; registers without rows are named as such. Confirmed in November 2026.
CheckpointWhat is checkedCriterion on fileRecord
Intake Incoming shell charcoalMoisture below 12%, fixed carbon 82% or more and volatile matter 14% or less; ash content and ash color checked, with no numeric limit on fileNone published
Size The dimensions of the piecesStated tolerance ±0.3 mm per side; measured with a digital caliper on 20 pieces, 4 times a day, and written downThe size-deviation log
Oven Moisture when the batch leaves the ovenMoisture of 2% at most, measured with a moisture meter on every oven loadThe batch COA register, moisture column
Packing day The temperature of the charcoalRecorded; 40 °C at mostThe stuffing and weathering records
Burn test Pieces burned on the bench3 pieces on an electric coil; time to light and burn time written downNone published
Drop test The strength of lit pieces350 per oven load, tested as lit pieces, after 10 minutes of heating and 5 minutes on a shisha bowl; dropped from 100 cm for cubes and 30 cm for hexagonal, dome and finger pieces onto a hard tiled floor; a piece passes when it does not break in at least 3 dropsThe drop-strength log
Packing Every piecePacked by the in-house team, who check every piece by handNone published
Every batch A retained sampleA sample of every batch, about 25 kg of each batch, kept for 5 yearsThe retained-sample log
A burn test shows what a measurement cannot: smell or smoke as a shisha charcoal briquette warms up, and the color of the ash it leaves.

The size criterion is the stated size tolerance. The stations behind each row are on the production process page.

3. What fails a batch

Four criteria fail a batch, and the factory names all four.

  • Smell or smoke on warming up
  • High ash
  • Cracks or breakage
  • Inconsistent size or density

Where in the line each criterion is applied, how the warm-up check is run and what happens to a failed batch are not on file, so this page does not describe them.

4. Where the results are published

Each result has a register, and the registers are gathered in one place.

The quality hub shows where each checkpoint result is published, as quality data and published records:

  • The batch COA register: confirmed rows published.
  • The size-deviation log: first rows being collected.
  • The drop-strength log: first rows being collected.
  • The stuffing and weathering records: first rows being collected.
  • The retained-sample log: first rows being collected.
A retained sample is a labeled portion of a batch kept at the factory, so a later question about that batch can be checked against the goods.

The physical record behind them is the retained sample: a sample of every batch, about 25 kg of each batch, kept for 5 years.

5. What is not on file yet

Five details of the checks are not on file yet, and they are left out here.

  • The sampling rate for each check.
  • The measuring tools.
  • Who releases a batch.
  • The flow for a batch that is held or rejected.
  • Whether results are kept per batch or per shift.

Tip

Ask, or send an inspector

Live video audits and factory visits are welcome. Buyers' third-party inspectors are welcome before shipment; the factory pays for the pre-shipment inspection. Both routes are on the verification page.

After the checks, the briquettes go to packing and loading.

Questions buyers ask

Is every piece checked, or a sample?
Both, at different points. At packing, the in-house team checks every piece by hand. The checks that fail a batch (smell or smoke on warming up, high ash, cracks or breakage, inconsistent size or density) are made on the batch; the sampling rate for each of them is not on file yet.
Are the in-line checks the same as the certificate of analysis?
No. In-line checks are the factory's own checks during production: the intake limits, the oven moisture limit, the criteria that fail a batch, and the hand check at packing. A certificate of analysis reports laboratory values for a batch. Those values are published in the batch COA register once its first rows are confirmed.

See the factory for yourself

Video audit on request; third-party inspection by the agency of your choice.