Quick answer
How do I compare two shisha charcoal quotes on the same basis?
Two quotes compare only after both are brought to price per metric ton, FOB, at the same load, packaging, spec, validity and payment terms. Convert each quote of coconut shell charcoal briquettes in seven steps (unit, incoterm and port, load, packaging, spec, validity, payment), then compare per ton and per container. Stop on a quote with no date, no COA values or a bank account outside the seller's name.
1. What like for like means
Like for like means both quotes stand on one basis before any price is read.
Definition
like-for-like quote comparison
A like-for-like quote comparison is the conversion of two or more supplier quotes to one basis — price per metric ton at the same incoterm and port, container load, packaging, specification, validity and payment terms — before their prices are compared.
A raw comparison misleads because each basis moves the price: a CIF figure includes freight, a per-carton figure hides the net weight, a printed retail box costs more to pack than a bulk carton, and tighter ash and moisture limits describe a different product. The conversions are the buyer's to ask for, and a supplier who cannot supply them has said something about the quote.
How prices and quotes on this site are dated and reviewed is set out in the editorial and review policy.
2. The seven normalizations, step by step
Bring each quote to one basis in seven steps, and ask the supplier for whatever a step needs.
-
Step 1
Convert to price per metric ton
Net charcoal weight. Express each price per metric ton of net charcoal. A per-carton price becomes a price per ton when multiplied by the number of cartons in 1,000 kg of net weight; a per-container price, when divided by the net tons loaded.
Verify: the net weight on the quote or on the carton mark, not the gross weight.
-
Step 2
Bring both to FOB at a named port
Same incoterm, same port. Compare at FOB, the price of the goods loaded at a named loading port. Ask a CIF supplier for the freight and insurance it included, or for an FOB price, so the charcoal is priced apart from the freight.
Verify: the incoterm and port named on the quote, under Incoterms 2020.
-
Step 3
Match the container load
Net tons per container. Ask for the net tons per 20 ft or 40 ft container for the same shape and packaging. The load changes with the format, so per-container prices compare only at the same load.
Verify: the load stated on the quote for that shape and packaging.
-
Step 4
Align the packaging
Inner unit, carton, print. Match the inner unit, the master or bulk carton and whether the box is printed or plain. Printed retail boxes and plain bulk cartons are different costs folded into the same price.
Verify: the packaging line on the quote.
-
Step 5
Compare the spec, not the grade name
COA values. Read the ash, moisture and fixed-carbon limits and a recent COA, not the grade name, because each factory names its own grades. A quote with no limits has no specification to compare.
Verify: a recent batch COA with the limits it is measured against.
-
Step 6
Check the validity
Date and duration. Note the date of each quote and how long it holds. An undated quote cannot be compared, and an expired one is no longer a price.
Verify: the quote date and its validity period.
-
Step 7
Set out the payment terms
Deposit, balance, account. Note the deposit share, the event that triggers the balance and the name on the receiving account. A larger deposit or an earlier balance moves cost and risk to the buyer.
Verify: the payment line, matched later on the proforma invoice.
Step 5 is the one most often skipped: a shisha charcoal grade is a trade name for a band of limits, and only the batch COA shows where one batch sits inside it.
3. A worked comparison of two quotes
Two quotes as received rarely share a basis; the table shows what each must be converted to before the prices are read side by side.
| Field | Quote A as received | Quote B as received | Normalized basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unit | Per 10 kg carton | Per metric ton | Per metric ton: A's carton price × 100 cartons |
| Incoterm | CIF destination port | FOB loading port | FOB: A less its stated freight and insurance |
| Load | Not stated | Stated for the shape | Ask A for its net tons per container |
| Packaging | Printed 1 kg boxes | Plain bulk cartons | Align both on one packaging |
| Spec | Grade name only | COA limits stated | Ask A for its COA values |
| Validity | Undated | Dated, valid 14 days | Ask A for a date and a validity period |
| Payment | 50% deposit | 30% deposit, balance on a copy of the B/L | State both terms side by side |
After conversion, quote A still lacks a load, COA values and a date, so it is not yet a price to compare. Once both quotes stand on one basis, the container cost of each follows from the price per ton and the net tons loaded.
4. Red flags in a quote
Six patterns in a quote are reasons to stop before any deposit, whatever the price.
Caution
Stop on these
- No date and no validity period.
- A grade name with no COA values behind it.
- A CIF price with no split of freight and insurance.
- A container load that does not fit the shape and packaging quoted.
- A deposit account that is not in the seller's legal name.
- Pressure to pay before a proforma invoice is issued.
Then run the bank-name check before any deposit, one step of factory verification. A low price on its own is not a red flag; a low price with any of these patterns is.
5. From the normalized quote to the proforma invoice
A normalized quote becomes a proforma invoice, and every field you normalized should reappear on it unchanged.
The proforma invoice restates the specification, quantity, unit price, incoterm, loading date, validity and payment terms. Compare it field by field with the normalized quote, using the proforma invoice fields a quote must match.
Note
This factory's basis
This factory quotes EXW, FOB, CFR and CIF, loading from Semarang, Surabaya or Jakarta. Payment on a first order is a 50% deposit, with the balance before stuffing; for a repeat buyer, a 10% deposit, with the balance after arrival.
No landed cost or duty figure is given here. The method from an FOB price to a landed cost is on the landed-cost method page, and the duty rate for your HS code comes from your customs broker.
Questions buyers ask
How do I convert a price per carton into a price per metric ton?
How do I compare a CIF quote with an FOB quote?
Should I compare quotes per ton or per container?
When is a quote suspiciously cheap?
Sources
- Incoterms 2020 (opens in new tab), International Chamber of Commerce — accessed